Difference between revisions of "Part:BBa C0171:Experience"

(Modeling crosstalk)
(Second order crosstalk: Combination of both cross-talk levels)
 
(27 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 26: Line 26:
 
|width='60%' valign='top'|
 
|width='60%' valign='top'|
  
= Characterization of two-order crosstalk on the promoter =
+
= Background information =
 +
 
 +
We used an ''E. coli'' TOP10 strain transformed with two medium copy plasmids (about 15 to 20 copies per plasmid and cell). The first plasmid contained the commonly used p15A origin of replication, a kanamycin resistance gene, and one out of three [https://parts.igem.org/Cell-cell_signalling cell-cell signaling promoters] ([[Part:BBa_R0062|pLux]], [[Part:BBa_R0079|pLas]], or [[Part:BBa_I14017|pRhl]]) followed by [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_B0034 RBS (BBa_B0034)] and superfolder green fluorescent protein (sfGFP). In general, for spacer and terminator sequences the parts [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_B0040 BBa_B0040] and [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_B0015 BBa_B0015] were used, respectively. The second plasmid contained the pBR322 origin (pMB1), which yields a stable two-plasmid system together with p15A, an ampicillin resistance gene, and a [[Part:BBa_J23100|strong promoter (BBa_J23100)]] chosen from the [https://parts.igem.org/Promoters/Catalog/Anderson Anderson promoter collection] followed by [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR (BBa_C0179)]. The detailed construct designs and full sequences (piG0042, piG0058, piG0059,piG0060) are [http://2014.igem.org/Team:ETH_Zurich/lab/sequences available here].
 +
 
 +
= Experimental Set-Up =
 +
The above described ''E. coli'' TOP10 strains were grown overnight in Lysogeny Broth (LB) containing kanamycin (50 μg/mL) and ampicillin (200 μg/mL) to an OD<sub>600</sub> of about 1.5 (37 °C, 220 rpm). As a reference, a preculture of the same strain lacking the sfGFP gene was included for each assay. The cultures were then diluted 1:40 in fresh LB containing the appropriate antibiotics and measured in triplicates in microtiter plate format on 96-well plates (200 μL culture volume) for 10 h at 37 °C with a Tecan infinite M200 PRO plate reader (optical density measured at 600 nm; fluorescence with an excitation wavelength of 488 nm and an emission wavelength of 530 nm). After 200 min we added the following concentrations of inducers ([[3OC6HSL|3OC6-HSL]], [[AHL|3OC12-HSL]], and [[AHL|C4-HSL]]): 10<sup>-4</sup> nM and 10<sup>4</sup> nM (from 100 mM stocks in DMSO). Attention: All the dilutions of [[AHL|3OC12-HSL]] should be made in DMSO in order to avoid precipitation. In addition, in one triplicate only H<sub>2</sub>O was added as a control. From the the obtained kinetic data, we calculated mean values and plotted the dose-response-curves for 200 min past induction.
 +
 
 +
= Characterization of crosstalk =
  
 
== Background information ==
 
== Background information ==
  
=== System considered ===
+
Here, we focus on the characterization of crosstalk of regulator [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR] and promoter [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl] with different [[AHL|AHLs]] and further crosstalk of [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0179 LasR] and inducer [[AHL|3OC12-HSL]] with the three promoters - [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_R0062 pLux], [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_R0079 pLas], and [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl]. Also we describe a combination of the two before mentioned types of crosstalk.
  
=== Modeling crosstalk ===
+
== First-order crosstalk ==
  
Each experimental data set was fitted to an Hill function using the Least Absolute Residual method.
+
In the first order crosstalk section we describe crosstalk of [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl] due to [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR] binding to inducers different from [[AHL|C4-HSL]], or [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl] itself binding a regulator-inducer pair different from [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR]-[[AHL|C4-HSL]].
  
[[File:ETHZ_HillEq.png|center|200px]]
+
=== First Level crosstalk: RhlR binds to different AHLs and activates the promoter ===
<p>The fitting of the graphs was performed using the following equation :<br><br>
+
In the conventional system [[AHL|C4-HSL]] binds to its corresponding regulator, [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR], and activates the [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_R0079 pRhl] promoter (Figure 1, green). However, RhlR can potentially also bind other AHLs and then activate pRhl (Figure 1, [[3OC6HSL|3OC6-HSL]] in light blue and [[AHL|3OC12-HSL]] in red).
rFluo = the relative fluorescence (absolute measured fluorescence value over OD)[au]<br>
+
a    = basal expression rate [au](“leakiness”)<br>
+
b = maximum expression rate [au]("full induction")<br>
+
n      = Hill coefficient (“cooperativity”)<br>
+
K<sub>m</sub>  = Half-maximal effective concentration (“sensitivity”)<br>
+
[AHL]=OHHL concentration [nM]</p>
+
<br clear="all"/>
+
  
{| border="1" class="wikitable" style="margin: 1em auto 1em auto;text-align:center;"
+
[[File:ETH Zurich 1crosstalkPrhl.png|400px|thumb|center| '''Figure 1 Overview of possible crosstalk of the [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR]/[https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl] system with three different [[AHL|AHLs]].''' Usually, [[AHL|C4-HSL]] binds to its corresponding regulator, [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR], and activates the [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl] promoter (green). However, [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0179 RhlR] may also bind [[3OC6HSL|3OC6-HSL]] (light blue) or [[AHL|3OC12-HSL]] (red) and then unintentionally activate [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl].]]
|+ Parameters of HillFunction for crosstalk with RhlR (with 95% confidence bounds)
+
!
+
! C4-HSL
+
! 3OC6-HSL
+
! 3OC12-HSL
+
|-
+
! Prhl
+
| a = 178.4 (174.9, 182) [au] <br> n = 1.053 (0.9489, 1.157)<br> Km = 1969 (1625, 2313) (nM)<br>b = 1736 (1629, 1842) [au]<br>
+
| a = 169.1 (155.2, 182.9) [au]<br> n = 0.507 (0.2303, 0.7837) <br> Km = 1.08e8(0, 2.681e10) (nM)<br> b = 9.708e4 (0, 1.192e7) [au]<br>
+
| a = 162.8 (150.4, 175.1) [au]<br> n = 0.404 (0, 0.998)<br> Km = 9.627e8 (0, 7.824e11) (nM)<br>b = 2.537e4 (0, 8.109e6) [au]<br>
+
|-
+
! Plux
+
|
+
|
+
| No crosstalk
+
|-
+
! Plas
+
| No crosstalk
+
| No crosstalk
+
| No crosstalk
+
|}
+
  
== First-order crosstalk ==
+
=== Second Level crosstalk: RhlR binds to C4-HSL, its natural AHL, and activates promoters different from pRhl===
  
=== First Level crosstalk: RhlR binds to different HSL and activates the promoter ===
+
In the conventional system [[AHL|C4-HSL]] binds to its corresponding regulator, [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR], and activates the [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl] promoter (Figure 2 right, green). However, [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0179 RhlR] can potentially also bind to additional [https://parts.igem.org/Cell-cell_signalling cell-cell signaling promoters] (Figure 2, [[Part:BBa_R0062|pLux]] in light blue and [[Part:BBa_R0079|pLas]] in red) and then activate genes different from the [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl] regulated gene of interest .
  
[[File:ETH Zurich 1crosstalkPrhl.png|400px|center]]
 
  
=== Second Level crosstalk: other regulatory proteins, like LuxR, bind to their natural HSL substrate and activates the promoter ===
 
  
[[File:ETH_Zurich_2crosstralkRrhl.png|400px|center]]
+
[[File:ETH_Zurich_2crosstralkRrhl.png|400px|thumb|center| '''Figure 2 Overview of possible crosstalk of the regulator [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR] with three different [https://parts.igem.org/Cell-cell_signalling cell-cell signaling promoters].''' Usually, [[AHL|C4-HSL]] binds to its corresponding regulator, [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR], and activates the [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl] promoter (green). However, [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR] may also bind [[Part:BBa_R0062|pLux]] (light blue) or [[Part:BBa_R0079|pLas]] (red) and then unintentionally activate 'off-target' gene expression.]]
  
 
== Second order crosstalk: Combination of both cross-talk levels  ==
 
== Second order crosstalk: Combination of both cross-talk levels  ==
  
 +
The second order crosstalk describes unintended activation of a [https://parts.igem.org/Cell-cell_signalling cell-cell signaling promoter] by a mixture of both the levels described above. The regulator [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0179 RhlR] binds an inducer different from [[AHL|3OC12-HSL]] and then activates a promoter different from [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl]. For example, the inducer [[3OC6HSL|3OC6-HSL]] (light blue), usually binding to the regulator [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0062 LuxR], could potentially interact with the [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0179 LasR] regulator (red) and together activate the promoter [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 pRhl] (green). This kind of crosstalk is explained in Figure 3.
 +
 +
 +
[[File:ETH Zurich 204 plux RhlR crosstalk.png|400px|thumb|center| '''Figure 3 Overview of possible crosstalk of the [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_R0062 pLux] promoter with both the regulator and inducer being unrelated to the promoter and each other.''' Usually, [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0062 LuxR] together with inducer [[3OC6HSL|3OC6-HSL]] activate their corresponding promoter [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_R0062 pLux] (light blue). However, [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_R0062 pLux] may also be activated by another regulator together with an unrelated inducer.  For example, the inducer [[AHL|3OC12-HSL]] (red) may interact with the [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_C0171 RhlR] regulator (green) and together activate [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_R0062 pLux] (light blue).]]
  
 
== Results ==
 
== Results ==
Line 109: Line 90:
 
|}
 
|}
  
 +
=== Modeling crosstalk ===
 +
 +
Each experimental data set was fitted to an Hill function using the Least Absolute Residual method.
 +
 +
[[File:ETHZ_HillEq.png|center|200px]]
 +
<p>The fitting of the graphs was performed using the following equation :<br><br>
 +
rFluo = the relative fluorescence (absolute measured fluorescence value over OD)[a.u.]<br>
 +
a    = basal expression rate [a.u.](“leakiness”)<br>
 +
b = maximum expression rate [a.u.]("full induction")<br>
 +
n      = Hill coefficient (“cooperativity”)<br>
 +
K<sub>m</sub>  = Half-maximal effective concentration (“sensitivity”)<br>
 +
[AHL]= AHL concentration [nM]</p>
 +
<br clear="all"/>
 +
 +
{| border="1" class="wikitable" style="margin: 1em auto 1em auto;text-align:center;"
 +
|+ Parameters of Hill function for crosstalk with RhlR (with 95% confidence bounds)
 +
!
 +
! [[AHL|C4-HSL]]
 +
! [[3OC6HSL|3OC6-HSL]]
 +
! [[AHL|3OC12-HSL]]
 +
|-
 +
! [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_I14017 Prhl]
 +
| a = 178.4 (174.9, 182) [a.u.] <br> n = 1.053 (0.9489, 1.157)<br> Km = 1969 (1625, 2313) [nM]<br>b = 1736 (1629, 1842) [a.u.]<br>
 +
| a = 169.1 (155.2, 182.9) [a.u.]<br> n = 0.507 (0.2303, 0.7837) <br> Km = 1.08e8(0, 2.681e10) [nM]<br> b = 9.708e4 (0, 1.192e7) [a.u.]<br>
 +
| a = 162.8 (150.4, 175.1) [a.u.]<br> n = 0.404 (0, 0.998)<br> Km = 9.627e8 (0, 7.824e11) [nM]<br>b = 2.537e4 (0, 8.109e6) [a.u.]<br>
 +
|-
 +
! [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_R0062 Plux]
 +
| a = 309.6 (283.6, 335.6) [a.u.]<br> n = 0.741 (0.6463, 0.8357) <br> Km = 2738 (1411, 4064) [nM] <br> b = 1.22e4 (1.045e4,1.45e4) [a.u.] <br>
 +
| a = 313.2 (296.8, 329.5) [a.u.]<br> n = 0.9427 (0.7565, 1.129)<br> Km = 1210 (565, 1855) [nM] <br> b = 8361 (7001, 9722) [a.u.] <br>
 +
| No crosstalk
 +
|-
 +
! [https://parts.igem.org/Part:BBa_R0079 Plas]
 +
| No crosstalk
 +
| No crosstalk
 +
| No crosstalk
 +
|}
  
 
|}
 
|}

Latest revision as of 15:35, 28 October 2014

This experience page is provided so that any user may enter their experience using this part.
Please enter how you used this part and how it worked out.

Applications of BBa_C0171

User Reviews

UNIQ1e0e846901e5662c-partinfo-00000000-QINU


••••

ETH Zurich 2014

Background information

We used an E. coli TOP10 strain transformed with two medium copy plasmids (about 15 to 20 copies per plasmid and cell). The first plasmid contained the commonly used p15A origin of replication, a kanamycin resistance gene, and one out of three cell-cell signaling promoters (pLux, pLas, or pRhl) followed by RBS (BBa_B0034) and superfolder green fluorescent protein (sfGFP). In general, for spacer and terminator sequences the parts BBa_B0040 and BBa_B0015 were used, respectively. The second plasmid contained the pBR322 origin (pMB1), which yields a stable two-plasmid system together with p15A, an ampicillin resistance gene, and a strong promoter (BBa_J23100) chosen from the Anderson promoter collection followed by RhlR (BBa_C0179). The detailed construct designs and full sequences (piG0042, piG0058, piG0059,piG0060) are [http://2014.igem.org/Team:ETH_Zurich/lab/sequences available here].

Experimental Set-Up

The above described E. coli TOP10 strains were grown overnight in Lysogeny Broth (LB) containing kanamycin (50 μg/mL) and ampicillin (200 μg/mL) to an OD600 of about 1.5 (37 °C, 220 rpm). As a reference, a preculture of the same strain lacking the sfGFP gene was included for each assay. The cultures were then diluted 1:40 in fresh LB containing the appropriate antibiotics and measured in triplicates in microtiter plate format on 96-well plates (200 μL culture volume) for 10 h at 37 °C with a Tecan infinite M200 PRO plate reader (optical density measured at 600 nm; fluorescence with an excitation wavelength of 488 nm and an emission wavelength of 530 nm). After 200 min we added the following concentrations of inducers (3OC6-HSL, 3OC12-HSL, and C4-HSL): 10-4 nM and 104 nM (from 100 mM stocks in DMSO). Attention: All the dilutions of 3OC12-HSL should be made in DMSO in order to avoid precipitation. In addition, in one triplicate only H2O was added as a control. From the the obtained kinetic data, we calculated mean values and plotted the dose-response-curves for 200 min past induction.

Characterization of crosstalk

Background information

Here, we focus on the characterization of crosstalk of regulator RhlR and promoter pRhl with different AHLs and further crosstalk of LasR and inducer 3OC12-HSL with the three promoters - pLux, pLas, and pRhl. Also we describe a combination of the two before mentioned types of crosstalk.

First-order crosstalk

In the first order crosstalk section we describe crosstalk of pRhl due to RhlR binding to inducers different from C4-HSL, or pRhl itself binding a regulator-inducer pair different from RhlR-C4-HSL.

First Level crosstalk: RhlR binds to different AHLs and activates the promoter

In the conventional system C4-HSL binds to its corresponding regulator, RhlR, and activates the pRhl promoter (Figure 1, green). However, RhlR can potentially also bind other AHLs and then activate pRhl (Figure 1, 3OC6-HSL in light blue and 3OC12-HSL in red).

Figure 1 Overview of possible crosstalk of the RhlR/pRhl system with three different AHLs. Usually, C4-HSL binds to its corresponding regulator, RhlR, and activates the pRhl promoter (green). However, RhlR may also bind 3OC6-HSL (light blue) or 3OC12-HSL (red) and then unintentionally activate pRhl.

Second Level crosstalk: RhlR binds to C4-HSL, its natural AHL, and activates promoters different from pRhl

In the conventional system C4-HSL binds to its corresponding regulator, RhlR, and activates the pRhl promoter (Figure 2 right, green). However, RhlR can potentially also bind to additional cell-cell signaling promoters (Figure 2, pLux in light blue and pLas in red) and then activate genes different from the pRhl regulated gene of interest .


Figure 2 Overview of possible crosstalk of the regulator RhlR with three different cell-cell signaling promoters. Usually, C4-HSL binds to its corresponding regulator, RhlR, and activates the pRhl promoter (green). However, RhlR may also bind pLux (light blue) or pLas (red) and then unintentionally activate 'off-target' gene expression.

Second order crosstalk: Combination of both cross-talk levels

The second order crosstalk describes unintended activation of a cell-cell signaling promoter by a mixture of both the levels described above. The regulator RhlR binds an inducer different from 3OC12-HSL and then activates a promoter different from pRhl. For example, the inducer 3OC6-HSL (light blue), usually binding to the regulator LuxR, could potentially interact with the LasR regulator (red) and together activate the promoter pRhl (green). This kind of crosstalk is explained in Figure 3.


Figure 3 Overview of possible crosstalk of the pLux promoter with both the regulator and inducer being unrelated to the promoter and each other. Usually, LuxR together with inducer 3OC6-HSL activate their corresponding promoter pLux (light blue). However, pLux may also be activated by another regulator together with an unrelated inducer. For example, the inducer 3OC12-HSL (red) may interact with the RhlR regulator (green) and together activate pLux (light blue).

Results

Table 1 Crosstalk matrix for the regulator LasR (BBa_C0171)

In all the measurements conducted to create this matrix the regulator RhlR was the basis and was induced in six different variations shown.

ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table Corner RhlR.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table C4-HSL.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table 3OC6-HSL.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table 3OC12-HSL.png
ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table pRhl.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table PrhlRef.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table PrhlRhlRLuxAHL.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table PrhlRhlRLasAHL.png
ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table pLux.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table PluxRhlRRhlAHL.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table PluxRhlRLuxAHL.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table PluxRhlRLasAHL.png
ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table pLas.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table PlasRhlRRhlAHL.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table PlasRhlRLuxAHL.png ETH Zurich 2014 qs-table PlasRhlRLasAHL.png

Modeling crosstalk

Each experimental data set was fitted to an Hill function using the Least Absolute Residual method.

ETHZ HillEq.png

The fitting of the graphs was performed using the following equation :

rFluo = the relative fluorescence (absolute measured fluorescence value over OD)[a.u.]
a = basal expression rate [a.u.](“leakiness”)
b = maximum expression rate [a.u.]("full induction")
n = Hill coefficient (“cooperativity”)
Km = Half-maximal effective concentration (“sensitivity”)
[AHL]= AHL concentration [nM]


Parameters of Hill function for crosstalk with RhlR (with 95% confidence bounds)
C4-HSL 3OC6-HSL 3OC12-HSL
Prhl a = 178.4 (174.9, 182) [a.u.]
n = 1.053 (0.9489, 1.157)
Km = 1969 (1625, 2313) [nM]
b = 1736 (1629, 1842) [a.u.]
a = 169.1 (155.2, 182.9) [a.u.]
n = 0.507 (0.2303, 0.7837)
Km = 1.08e8(0, 2.681e10) [nM]
b = 9.708e4 (0, 1.192e7) [a.u.]
a = 162.8 (150.4, 175.1) [a.u.]
n = 0.404 (0, 0.998)
Km = 9.627e8 (0, 7.824e11) [nM]
b = 2.537e4 (0, 8.109e6) [a.u.]
Plux a = 309.6 (283.6, 335.6) [a.u.]
n = 0.741 (0.6463, 0.8357)
Km = 2738 (1411, 4064) [nM]
b = 1.22e4 (1.045e4,1.45e4) [a.u.]
a = 313.2 (296.8, 329.5) [a.u.]
n = 0.9427 (0.7565, 1.129)
Km = 1210 (565, 1855) [nM]
b = 8361 (7001, 9722) [a.u.]
No crosstalk
Plas No crosstalk No crosstalk No crosstalk


Antiquity

This review comes from the old result system and indicates that this part did not work in some test.

UNIQ1e0e846901e5662c-partinfo-00000003-QINU

No review score entered. Northwestern 2011

The 2011 Northwestern iGEM team used this part as a part of our Pseudomonas Aeruginosa biosensor. We were able to successfully express LasR (C0171) continuously in our system. BBa K575024